FLBear5630 said:
Osodecentx said:
whiterock said:
FLBear5630 said:
whiterock said:
FLBear5630 said:
whiterock said:
FLBear5630 said:
boognish_bear said:
She is a real problem, she is even going against Trump now.
she's speaking for a majority of the party w/r/t the Speaker.....
Why is it always the conservatives who are the problem for resisting leadership, but not moderates who do exactly the same thing?
Majority of the Party???? I don't know what Party you belong to. Johnson's Conservative credentials are better than Greene's! For someone that seems to pride himself on being an analyst, strategic thinker you support some very strange positions. You know better than most that Johnson, ANY GOP Speaker today, is limited in what they can do and get accomplished. Yet, you support whack job, shrill emotional outburst like yesterday that do nothing but create chaos and give more power to the Dems. Johnson knows getting Trump elected is Job #1, the rest is just trying to keep the Nation on the rails until the election.
By the way, she got slapped down by her own Party and the GOP Nominee. Look at the vote. Don't think she is in tuned with the Party.
Worse yet, she has NO concept of how to actually accomplish anything. Her and Gaetz just go off the rails run by pure emotion. Meanwhile, the Dems act as a block and everything is a concerted effort. They are setting Trump and the neo-GOP back decades...
That is my name for the current GOP - neo-GOP. Because it sure ain't Reagan and Goldwater's GOP.
Conservative credentials aside, he facilitated the advance of items important to the left and got nothing in return. He did it on military aid. He did it on FISA courts. What did "we" get in return? (nothing that I'm aware of.) She is expressing a view held by a majority of Republicans, who are frustrated that we spent all this money on Israel and Ukraine (which did need spending) and got nothing done to stop the flow of people across the southern border (which does need stopping).
Fact is, moderates in the party are just as unreasonable as MTG. Moderates are threatening to cross aisles if they don't get their way, too. Etc......
Why is it always the responsibility of the Republicans to compromise? Democrats were willing to let Ukraine go down in defeat to protect their border policy. Why are they not the problem here? (answer: because they know GOP moderates will bend to the urge to be the adult in the room.)
Until Democrats are filled with terror that the GOP actually is ready to say no, sit down under a shad tree, and start peeling peaches while the whole show burns to the ground, Democrats will continue to make maximalist demands and wait until Republicans cave.
Several issues here.
First, Johnson and through and through Conservative said point blank his view on supporting Ukraine and Israel changed when he saw the intel. You of everyone on this Board should respect that answer. You know he is not at liberty to share, but if a guy with his pedigree is saying there are things you don't know, and we need to fund this. It should carry weight,
actually, his statement about "seeing the intel" concerned the FISA court. He shoulda said "fine, let the FISA court collapse. We'll write better law on a new one next week." And then be prepared to in fact let it collapse and start writing law on a replacement. Until Democrats understand that we are prepared do do exactly that, they will keep winning.
Second. that ship has sailed. The GOP is dysfunctional. You have to ask why? You say moderates are willing to leave, why? The Dem Moderates are ok with the most radical positions of the Squad.
Read what you wrote there. Dem Moderates go along with ALL of the radical positions of the Squad....they NEVER publicly criticize them. Where are all the stories about the Dem moderates saving the party from the Squad, undermining the far left to work with Republicans? Blue Dogs, Blue Dogs, wherefore art thou, Blue Dogs?
What is the GOP extreme asking that is so unpalatable that they are willing to cross.
Like what. GIve us an example of an extreme position that Gaetz and MTG are demanding? I disagree with them on Ukraine funding. Very unwise positions they have taken. But is it really "extreme" to demand fiscal restraint? Is it really extreme to suggest the problem on the border is worse? I mean, where, EXACTLY is the extreme position analogous to the ideological nonsense of the Squad?
Calling them names and yelling at them is not gonna get it done.
Equating MTG with the squad and calling her a radical is not gonna get it done, either, when all she's doing is standing up for things that are broadly popular, if not majoritarian positions within the party.
MAGA needs to take a look in the mirror if life long GOPers are willing to retire and cross than support what they want. But, seems you prefer to call them names. Gaetz and Greene hurt the Party.
And the moderates who create them don't?
Never fight with your base, man. Never. It is a bullet train to the hurt locker.
MTG is the Republican base?
Based on the vote, she is in no way his base. Hell, even Trump stood up for him. The MAGA group wants us to believe they are the base, but they are not. They are fringe right,
They are about 50% of the party....that is certainly a big big part of the base.
Because of party politics and the fact that plenty of More War/More Immigration 1st Republicans run as fake MAGA candidates they have less representatives in Congress than they should...but they are a big voting base of the party.
https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2021/11/09/the-republican-coalition/[The most deeply conservative group in the political typology
Faith and Flag Conservatives make up 23% of Republicans and independents who lean toward the Republican Party, making them one of the two largest groups in the GOP coalition. Conservative across the board, they are one of the most politically engaged typology groups...Faith and Flag Conservatives say their political views are conservative, including 35% who describe themselves as "very conservative." They are overwhelmingly White and Christian and stand out for their views on the role of religion in public life. They are among Donald Trump's strongest supporters....
Populist Right 23% of Republicans and Republican leaners are one of the two largest groups in the GOP coalition, along with Faith and Flag Conservatives. They also are deeply conservative and reliably vote Republican. Yet they differ from Committed Conservative on two key dimensions: They hold hard-line immigration views and are highly critical of the economic system.]
F&F Cons and Populist Right Cons are around 50% of the party.